WTO: 2012 NEWS ITEMS

AGRICULTURE NEGOTIATIONS: INFORMAL MEETING


NOTE:
THIS NEWS STORY is designed to help the public understand developments in the WTO. While every effort has been made to ensure the contents are accurate, it does not prejudice member governments’ positions.

“INFORMAL MEETING” means there are no minutes.

MORE:
> News: agriculture talks

> Agriculture negotiations
> Modalities phase

> The Doha Round

Need help on downloading?
> Find help here

 

The story so far 

2000: Agriculture negotiations launched(March). See backgrounder

2001: Doha Development Agenda launched. Agriculture included (November)

2004: “Framework” agreed (August)

2005: Further agreements in Hong Kong Ministerial Conference (December)

2006: Draft modalities (June)

2007: Revised draft modalities (July)

2007-2008: Intensive negotiations with working documents (September-January)

2008: Revised draft modalities (February, May and July)

2008: The July 2008 package full coverage and the chair’s report

2008: Revised draft modalities (February, May, July and December)

“My sense is that overall we are still at the stage of clarifying where things are — with the consultations to date and today’s discussions being an important contribution to that — before we determine where that takes us,” he said. “We need to listen carefully to each other.”

This informal meeting of the agriculture negotiations was open to the full membership, and was called so that Ambassador Adank could report on his consultations and for delegations to express their views.

It was the first meeting in the agriculture talks since the December 2011 Geneva Ministerial Conference when WTO ministers acknowledged that the Doha Development Agenda talks are at an impasse and called for a change of approach.

Members had told him that the search for a new approach would have to observe some conditions, the chairperson said. Some focused on subjects that concern them, some warned against backward steps from what has already been achieved in the talks as a result of heavy negotiating investment, he reported.

Until recently, the talks had focused on 10 particularly difficult remaining issues. Ambassador Adank said negotiators broadly acknowledged that in the current climate, progress on these issues might not be possible. At the same time some members said refocusing the talks could mean the large amount already achieved would be lost, he said.

Differences of opinion include which subjects might be agreed ahead of a comprehensive deal (the “early harvest”) and whether any political decisions can be taken in the present climate, Ambassador Adank said.

He urged negotiators to continue to talk to each other so that they can understand each other’s positions. He would also keep in close contact with them, he said.

“I will continue to consult with members, and to report on further developments,” he concluded. “I will not at this stage suggest a timing for a further open-ended informal [meeting], but will consult in due course on when this might be useful to schedule.”

 

The discussion

Speakers’ comments confirmed his assessment. Some said their groups will continue to test ideas and present the results as the next meeting.

Some suggested the issues of export competition — export subsidies and the parallel issues of disciplines on export credit, food aid and state trading enterprise, which could contain hidden subsidies — is ripe for an early agreement, including the declaration at the 2005 Hong Kong Ministerial Conference on eliminating the subsidies by 2013. Some also said members should deliver what the Hong Kong conference called for on cotton.

Others said the export competition commitment was always tied to agreement in all areas in agriculture as well as on geographical indications in intellectual property.

Some said that whatever is agreed has to strike a balance between all three “pillars” in the talks (market access, domestic support and export competition). Several repeated issues of concern to them.

Several said agriculture remains central to the whole Doha Round. They all said they are committed to working with each other and with the chairperson to find a way forward.

Speakers included India (for the G-33), Australia (for the Cairns Group and itself), Dominican Republic (for small and vulnerable economies), Honduras, Chinese Taipei (for countries that recently joined the WTO), Brazil (for the G-20 and itself), Switzerland (for the G-10), Argentina, the EU, Cuba and China. (More on the coalitions, here.)

 

Next

Members continue to consult. Chair will call meeting for full membership later.

 

Audio

Use these links to download the audio files or to listen to what he said in the meeting:

The chair’s statements:

 

Explanations

This was an informal agriculture negotiations meeting of the full membership, officially an “Informal Open-Ended Special Session” of the Agriculture Committee.

Modalities : The way or method of doing something — in this case, how to cut tariffs, enlarge quotas and reduce subsidies and support, along with flexibilities to deal with various sensitivities. The core methods are formulas for cutting tariffs and supports, with a number ways of achieving the flexibilities or tightening disciplines. Once the modalities have been agreed, countries can apply the formulas to tariffs on thousands of products and to various support programmes.

10 key outstanding issues : Chairperson David Walker describes the issues he is currently dealing with as topics that are “bracketed and otherwise annotated” in the 2008 documents. He listed these issues and his assessments in his 22 March 2010 report to the Trade Negotiations Committee:

  • Blue box — product-specific limits (paragraph 42 of the 2008 draft)
  • Cotton (pars 54/55 and chair’s introduction)
  • Sensitive products — designation (par 71)
  • Tariff cap (par 76)
  • Tariff quota creation (par 83)
  • Tariff simplification (par 104)
  • Special products (par 129)
  • Special safeguard mechanism — SSM (par 144/145)
  • Tropical and diversification products (par 148 and annex G)
  • Long-standing preferences and preference erosion (par 149 and annex H)

 

 

Jargon buster 

Place the cursor over a term to see its definition:

 
About negotiating texts:

• bracketed

• “Job document”

• modality, modalities

• schedules

• templates

 
Issues:

• Amber box

• Blue box

• box

• de minimis

• distortion

• export competition

• Green box

• pro-rating

• sensitive products

• special products (SP)

• special safeguard mechanism (SSM)

• tariff line

• tariff quota

• the three pillars

> More jargon: glossary
> More explanations

RSS news feeds

> Problems viewing this page?
Please contact [email protected] giving details of the operating system and web browser you are using.