MORE:
> Disputes in the WTO
> Find disputes cases
> Find disputes documents
> Disputes chronologically
> Disputes by subject
> Disputes by country
NOTE:
This summary has been prepared by the WTO Secretariat’s Information and
External Relations Division to help public understanding about developments
in WTO disputes. It is not a legal interpretation of the issues, and it is
not intended as a complete account of the issues. These can be found in
the reports themselves and in the minutes of the Dispute Settlement
Body’s meetings.
Prior to the meeting, the DSB chair announced that the US had appealed the panel report (WT/DS384/R and WT/DS386/R) which examined its measures regarding mandatory country of origin labelling (COOL). Consequently, the report was not considered for adoption by the DSB and this issue was removed from the agenda
As Antigua and Barbuda could not attend the DSB meeting, the agenda item on internet gambling (DS285) was not discussed.
Adoption of reports
DS353: United States — Measures Affecting Trade in Large Civil Aircraft — Second Complaint
The DSB adopted the panel and Appellate Body reports (WT/DS353/R and WT/DS353/AB/R) on the US subsidies to its civil aircraft industry. The panel and Appellate Body reports were respectively released on 31 March 2011 and 12 March 2012.
The EU said it had demonstrated that certain measures by US federal state and local governments provide subsidies to Boeing that are inconsistent with the US obligations under WTO rules. According to the EU, over the last decades, Boeing had benefitted from billions of dollars worth of aeronautics research and development, subsidies from the NASA and the US Department of Defence. The EU said that Boeing had also benefitted from federal tax breaks under the Foreign Sales Corporation and Extraterritorial Income Exclusion legislation. The EU added that Boeing was granted a large number of state and local subsidies in Washington State, Kansas and Illinois. The EU expected that, in light of the long history of WTO inconsistent adverse effects that the US federal state and local subsidies have created, the US would move quickly to comply with its obligations and withdraw the subsidies or remove their adverse effects within the six-month period provided by the WTO Subsidies and Countervailing Agreement (article 7.9). The EU remained ready to work with the US to achieve that end.
The US said that the Boeing dispute came about because seven years ago, the US sought to challenge launch aid, the form of financing whereby the EU member states pay for the development of Airbus aircraft, and airbus does not have to repay if the aircraft proves unsuccessful. According to the US, these subsidies were responsible for every single airbus aircraft ever produced and caused massive adverse effects to US trade. The US said that in response to this dispute, the EU argued that US subsidies were bigger and more distortive of trade. The US said that the panel and Appellate Body reports had vindicated its position. The US added that the reports rejected most of the EU claims of adverse effects.
The US also referred to a procedural issue in relation to article 17.5 of the Dispute Settlement Understanding (DSU) and added that the Appellate Body should provide members the same degree of transparency on the circumstances under which a report is presented for adoption outside the 90-day period, as the Appellate Body formerly provided to members prior to 2011. Japan supported the US comments on this issue.
Canada expressed its views on the nature of the causal analysis required to support a panel finding that subsidies cause serious prejudice and on the scope of the specificity analysis under article 2.1(a) of the WTO Subsidies and Countervailing Agreement.
Implementation
DS394, DS395 and DS398: China — Measures related to the exportation of various raw materials
At the last DSB meeting on 22 February 2012, members adopted the panel and Appellate Body reports (WT/DS394/R — corr.1 and add.1. WT/DS394/AB/R; WT/DS395/R — corr.1 and add.1. WT/DS395/AB/R; WT/DS398/R — corr.1 and add.1. WT/DS398/AB/R) which reviewed China’s export restrictions on raw materials.
According to article 21.3 of the DSU, China had 30 days after the adoption of the reports to inform the DSB of its intentions regarding implementation.
China informed the DSB that it would need a reasonable period of time to implement the DSB ruling and stood ready to discuss this issue with the EU, Mexico and the US.
The EU said that Chinese export restrictions continue to significantly distort the market and created competitive advantages to the Chinese manufacturing industry to the detriment of foreign competitors.
The US looked forward to China promptly removing the exports constraints.
Mexico hoped that China would comply with the DSB recommendations and would promptly eliminate the export restrictions at issue in this dispute.
DS405: European Union — Anti-dumping measures on certain footwear from China
At the last DSB meeting on 22 February 2012, members adopted the panel report (WT/DS405/R) which examined anti-dumping measures imposed by the EU on Chinese footwear.
According to article 21.3 of the DSU, the EU had 30 days after the adoption of the reports to inform the DSB of its intentions regarding implementation.
The EU informed the DSB that it would need a reasonable period of time to implement the DSB ruling and stood ready to discuss this issue with China.
China called upon the EU to implement the DSB recommendations as soon as possible. China added that it was ready to discuss the reasonable period of time for implementation with the EU.
DS415, DS416, DS417 and DS418: Dominican Republic — Safeguard measures on imports of polypropylene bags and tubular fabric
At the last DSB meeting on 22 February 2012, members adopted the panel reports (WT/DS415/R — WT/DS416/R — WT/DS417/R — WT/DS418/R and add.1) which reviewed the safeguard measures imposed by the Dominican Republic on imports of plastic bags and tubular fabric.
According to article 21.3 of the DSU, the Dominican Republic had 30 days after the adoption of the reports to inform the DSB of its intentions regarding implementation.
The Dominican Republic said that it would implement the DSB ruling by 30 April 2012.
El Salvador, Guatemala, and Costa Rica said that the only way to implement the ruling was to eliminate the safeguard measure.
Appellate Body members selection process
The DSB chair, Ambassador Elin Østebø Johansen (Norway), recalled members that they had until 30 March 2012 to propose candidates to replace Appellate Body member Shotaro Oshima, who resigned earlier this year. Ambassador Johansen informed members that so far three candidates had been nominated, one from Kenya and two from Japan.
With regards to the reappointment of Appellate Body member Yuejiao Zhang whose mandate would expire on 31 May 2012 and who expressed her willingness to be reappointed for a second four-year term, Ambassador Johansen said that consultations regarding her reappointment had started and that this process would be continued by her successor Ambassador Shahid Bashir (Pakistan).
New DSB chair
Members elected Ambassador Shahid Bashir of Pakistan as the new chair of the DSB for a one-year term.
Next meeting
The next regular meeting of the DSB will be held on 24 April 2012.
> Problems viewing this page?
Please contact [email protected] giving details of the operating system and web browser you are using.
