NOTE:
THIS NEWS ITEM IS DESIGNED TO HELP THE PUBLIC UNDERSTAND
DEVELOPMENTS IN THE WTO. WHILE EVERY EFFORT HAS BEEN MADE TO ENSURE THE
CONTENTS ARE ACCURATE, IT DOES NOT PREJUDICE MEMBER GOVERNMENTS’
POSITIONS. THE OFFICIAL RECORD IS IN THE MEETING’S MINUTES
SEE ALSO:
> intellectual property (TRIPS)
> TRIPS and health
> TRIPS and biodiversity
> geographical indications
> all TRIPS issues
> TRIPS news
This was a meeting of the “special session” of the
WTO’s Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS) Council,
which is the forum for negotiating the
geographical indications register for wines and spirits within the
Doha Round.
Following a procedure proposed by the chairperson, Zambian Ambassador Darlington
Mwape, they focused on what information is taken into account when a term is
proposed for protection, and how this would be affected by the proposed
register. Delegates also considered how to deal with a claim that a term
is generic and should therefore escape protection.
Amb. Mwape has identified these as comfort-raising questions to be tackled under
the heading of the legal effects or consequences of a term being registered,
which he describes as the biggest stumbling block to agreement.
Several delegations that had not previously done so (Turkey and Thailand)
described how their domestic systems work, broadening the base of countries
taking part actively in this phase of the negotiations. Some (Australia, the EU,
Japan, Chinese Taipei, Switzerland, Chile and the US) fine-tuned the responses
they gave in the June meeting.
Similarities and differences
The debate showed some that domestic practices have
some common features. In particular, when domestic authorities decide whether to
protect specific trademarks or geographical indications, they do consult various
sources of information and take them into account. They also ensure that
obligations under bilateral and international treaties are respected.
They differ on whether an agreed weight should be attached to certain types of
information (such as the fact that a term is protected in the country of
origin). They also differ on who bears the burden of proof when a term is
proposed for protection but could be ineligible because it has become generic.
Broadly, the latest versions of rival proposals for the register include
different views of how a term’s registration in the multilateral system should
affect its protection in a country, following the TRIPS Agreement’s principle
that countries are free to choose how their domestic systems meet the
agreement’s minimum standards.
The US, Australia, New Zealand, Canada and their “joint proposal” allies say the
term’s registration should be “taken into account”.
The EU and fellow-signatories of document TN/C/W/52 say countries should view a
term’s registration as prima facie (“at first sight”) evidence that a term meets
the definition of a geographical indication and therefore could be eligible for
protection — whether or not it would eventually be protected in a country would
depend on other criteria under that country’s intellectual property system.
This difference also has implications for how a term might be challenged under a
country’s legal system, for example on the grounds that it has become generic.
(Hong Kong, China has a third proposal, which it has advocated as a middle
ground approach. Details of all three proposals are
Comfort
Amb. Mwape said that the focus on their own systems
should make countries more comfortable with the ideas in the different
proposals, and help to avoid repeated “rhetorical debates”.
Most speakers did describe how their countries’ systems worked in these areas,
or asked questions about each other’s systems, referring to descriptions made in
the June meeting.
The EU proposed moving the analysis further, asking countries to describe how
alternative proposals would be handled in their systems. It compared the
implications of the “joint proposal” and its own TN/C/W/52, concluding that the
“joint proposal” would add little value to what it is already doing.
Members did occasionally revert to “rhetorical debating”, arguing for their
proposals and for or against linking the register to other issues. Document
TN/C/W/52 links the proposal on the register with two other issues: “extension”
for geographical indications and
“disclosure” for patent applications based on genetic resources or traditional
knowledge or both.
Doha Round brainstorming
Switzerland and Chile reported to the meeting on TRIPS
brainstorming sessions among a small group of ambassadors as part of the variety
of discussions taking place on the Doha Round (described in
Director-General
Pascal Lamy’s report to the Trade Negotiations Committee)
They said they had asked the Secretariat for information on how the terms “prima
facie”, “burden of proof” and “due diligence” are used in the WTO system for
settling legal disputes.
Some members said they would like the reply to be shared. Switzerland said
transparency would be respected, and Chairperson Darlington Mwape said
participants in the brainstorming groups would be invited to continue to report
to members, noting that the separate small group discussions were not an
official part of the Special Session negotiations.
NEXT: (could
be changed)
3 March, 9 June and 27 October 2011, in the same week as the regular TRIPS
Council meetings
Chairperson: Ambassador Darlington Mwape of Zambia
Current proposals
Three alternatives are currently on the table:
-
The Joint Proposal TN/IP/W/10/Rev.2 from Argentina, Australia, Canada, Chile, Costa Rica, Dominican Republic, Ecuador, El Salvador, Guatemala, Honduras, Japan, Rep.Korea, Mexico, New Zealand, Nicaragua, Paraguay, Chinese Taipei, South Africa, the US. This envisages the register as a database. Members would choose whether or not to participate in the register. The intellectual property authorities of participating members would consult the database when considering protection for individual trademarks or geographical indications within their countries.
-
TN/C/W/52 of 19 July 2008, from over 100 WTO members, which includes a modified and stripped-down version of the EU’s original proposal for the multilateral register. It is now in the form of proposed “modalities” or a blueprint of the final outcome, with details to be negotiated later. Described as a negotiated compromise among the sponsors, the proposal envisages a system applying to all members although members could choose whether or not to register their own geographical indications.
All members would have to take a term’s registration “into account” and treat it as “prima facie” evidence (first sight, or preliminary, before further investigation) that the term meets the definition of a geographical indication. Further procedures for that term within each country would be handled entirely within the country’s domestic legal system. These include confirmation that the term is an eligible geographical indication, possible challenges, and whether it is subject to exceptions such as because the term is generic.
(Previously the EU had proposed that if a term is registered the assumption — the legal phrase is “irrebuttable presumption” — would be that it should be protected in all WTO members except those that have successfully challenged the term.)
Opponents of this proposal also object to the link with two other intellectual property issues: “extending” to all products the enhanced protection currently given to wines and spirits; and requiring patent applicants to disclose the origin of genetic materials and related traditional knowledge used in their inventions.
• geographical indications (GIs): Place names (or words associated with a place) used to identify products (for example, “Champagne”, “Tequila” or “Roquefort”) which have a particular quality, reputation or other characteristic because they come from that place.
• modalities: The way or method of doing something — in the Doha Development Agenda negotiations these are blueprints for the final deal, eg, how to cut tariffs, and reduce agricultural subsidies and support, along with flexibilities to deal with various sensitivities. Once the modalities have been agreed, countries can apply the formulas to tariffs on thousands of products and to various support programmes.
• special sessions: meetings of WTO councils and committees focusing only on the Doha Development Agenda negotiations.
• TRIPS: Trade-related aspects of intellectual property rights.
> More jargon: glossary
> Problems viewing this page?
Please contact [email protected] giving details of the operating system and web browser you are using.
