MORE:
> Disputes in the WTO
> Find disputes cases
> Find disputes documents
> Disputes chronologically
> Disputes by subject
> Disputes by country
NOTE:
This summary has been prepared by the WTO Secretariat’s Information and
External Relations Division to help public understanding about developments
in WTO disputes. It is not a legal interpretation of the issues, and it is
not intended as a complete account of the issues. These can be found in
the reports themselves and in the minutes of the Dispute Settlement
Body’s meetings.
Panels established
DS491: US — Anti-Dumping and Countervailing Measures on Certain Coated Paper from Indonesia
Indonesia reiterated its view, expressed at the previous DSB meeting that the US dumping, subsidy, and threat of injury determinations on certain coated paper from Indonesia appeared to be inconsistent with the US obligations under the GATT 1994, the Anti-Dumping Agreement and the Subsidies and Countervailing Measures (SCM) Agreement. In that regard, Indonesia made its second request for the DSB to establish a panel to examine this dispute. The US reiterated its view that the actions in question were fully consistent with its obligations under the WTO Agreement. The DSB established a panel. Canada, China, EU, Korea and Turkey reserved their third-party rights to participate in the panel’s proceedings.
DS495: Korea — Import Bans, and Testing and Certification Requirements for Radionuclides
Japan reiterated its concern, expressed at the previous DSB meeting, that Korea had adopted and maintains sanitary and phytosanitary (SPS) measures that are inconsistent with several provisions of the SPS Agreement. Japan recalled Korea’s concerns, expressed at the previous DSB meeting, about delays in the dispute settlement process which, in Japan’s view, equally applied to this dispute. Japan, for the second time, requested the DSB to establish a panel to examine this dispute. Korea regretted Japan’s request and maintained its view that its measures are in conformity with the WTO Agreement. The DSB established a panel. China, EU, Guatemala, India, New Zealand, Norway, Russia, Chinese Taipei and the US reserved their third-party rights to participate in the panel’s proceedings.
DS490: Indonesia — Safeguard on Certain Iron or Steel Products
Chinese Taipei recalled that at the previous DSB meeting it had requested the establishment of a panel to examine the safeguard measure imposed by Indonesia which, in its view, was inconsistent with the WTO Agreements. Indonesia noted that Chinese Taipei had misidentified the specific measure at issue and thus did not satisfy the requirements of the Dispute Settlement Understanding (DSU). In that regard, Indonesia was of the view that a panel should not be established until the panel request is fully consistent with the provisions of the DSU. Chinese Taipei said that there was merely a typo and that a panel should still be established. The Chairman noted that the request for panel establishment was on the DSB’s Agenda for the second time and that, in line with the DSU provisions, the DSB would establish a panel. He noted however that Indonesia could raise this issue before the panel. The DSB established a panel. Chile, China, EU, Korea, Russia, US and Viet Nam reserved their third-party rights to participate in the panel’s proceedings.
DS497: Brazil — Certain Measures Concerning Taxation and Charges
Japan expressed its concerns regarding Brazil’s introduction of a number of measures that enable domestic companies to reduce their obligation to pay certain internal taxes and charges. These measures had serious trade-restrictive effects on a broad range of products imported into Brazil from Japan and other members. In Japan’s view, Brazil’s measures were inconsistent with its obligations under the GATT 1994, the Trade-related Investment Measures (TRIMs) Agreement and the SCM Agreement. Consultations held in September 2015 did not resolve this dispute; hence Japan’s request for panel establishment.
Brazil said that its challenged programmes are part of its efforts to promote economic development in line with the WTO’s objectives and principles. In its view, Japan was advocating a broad interpretation of the disciplines relating to national treatment and local content. Brazil considered that its tax and regulatory regimes were not linked to the domestic origin of goods but rather to the compliance, by interested companies, with targets related to technological innovation, workforce capacity-building, safety and sustainable development. Brazil said that it would not object to the establishment of a panel.
The EU said that it shared Japan’s concerns and noted that the EU had also raised a similar matter against Brazil in DS472. Japan said that, in relation to the EU’s dispute with Brazil (DS472), a panel had already been established and Japan would accept the same panellists. In that regard, Japan was ready to cooperate with the panel in harmonising the timetable. The EU agreed with Japan’s suggestion. Brazil said that it was prepared to consult with the panel and the parties. The DSB established a panel. Argentina, Australia, China, EU, India, Korea, Russia and US reserved their third-party rights to participate in the panel’s proceedings.
Panel request rejected
DS496: Indonesia — Safeguard on Certain Iron or Steel Products
Viet Nam said that it was concerned about Indonesia’s imposition of a safeguard measure on imports of certain flat-rolled product of iron or non-alloy steel, pursuant to a positive finding by Indonesia’s investigating authority of threat of serious injury caused by increased imports. In Viet Nam’s view, Indonesia’s measure is inconsistent with the relevant provisions of the GATT 1994 and the Agreement on Safeguards. Consultations held in July 2015 did not resolve the dispute and, in that regard, Viet Nam requested the DSB to establish a panel to examine this dispute. Should the panel be established, Viet Nam requested that the same panel that would examine Chinese Taipei’s complaint regarding the same measure (DS490) should examine Viet Nam’s complaint.
Indonesia said that it had clearly explained to Viet Nam the legal and factual aspects of its safeguard measure which, in its view, was consistent with the Safeguards Agreement and its own domestic safeguard regulation. Indonesia was therefore not in a position to agree to the establishment of a panel. Chinese Taipei said that it agreed with Viet Nam’s request regarding a single panel to examine DS490 and DS496. The DSB deferred the establishment of a panel.
Status reports and statements
Six status reports were presented and statements were made regarding three implementation matters.
Appellate Body reappointments and delays in the dispute settlement process
Under “Other Business”, the Chairman made two statements.
On the possible reappointment of two Appellate Body (AB) members, the Chairman reported that consultations were still ongoing and he encouraged delegations with views on these matters to contact him directly. He reminded delegations that a decision on these matters would have to be taken by the DSB at the latest at its regular meeting scheduled for 25 November 2015.
The Chairman informed the DSB of the Director-General’s intention to make a presentation on the current challenges facing the dispute settlement system. The DG will brief members at the DSB meeting of October 2015 on the steps he has taken since the September 2014 DSB meeting to address the situation. The DG will also speak about the current challenges and what he intends to do going forward.
The Chairman noted that as the DG and several members had made clear at the September 2014 DSB meeting and was clear from the discussions at the August 2015 DSB meeting, resolving this issue is not the task of the DG and Secretariat alone. Members also have a role to play in finding solutions. In that regard, he invited delegations with views, ideas and suggestions to contact him directly.
The Chairman said that he was ready to hold informal consultations and to assist members in finding appropriate solutions and in identifying how to ensure that the dispute settlement system will continue to serve members well in the future. He encouraged members to give careful thought to this matter. Korea said that it looked forward to concrete proposals from the DG on what the Secretariat planned to do to address this issue, as well as what members can do.
Next meeting
The next regular meeting of the DSB is scheduled for 28 October 2015.
> Problems viewing this page?
Please contact [email protected] giving details of the operating system and web browser you are using.
