RESEARCH AND ANALYSIS: WORKING PAPERS
Canary in a Coal Mine
How trade concerns at the Goods Council reflect the changing landscape of trade frictions at the WTO
This paper studies the under-explored yet critical role of WTO's regular bodies, particularly focusing on the discussions of "trade concerns" within the Goods Council, its subsidiary bodies, as well as the General Council. These discussions are pivotal for the governance of international trade and are key in resolving trade frictions among WTO Members, going beyond the conventional realms of diplomatic negotiation and legal adjudication.
By scrutinizing trade concerns deliberated within these bodies over the past 29 years, this paper provides insights into their indispensable function in enhancing policy transparency, facilitating constructive dialogue on trade measures, and offering a platform for members to voice concerns over the trade practices of others. Our analysis, based on a new methodology that focuses on the number of interventions rather than the number of trade concerns, uncovers a growing trend where Members are increasingly leveraging these discussions to navigate and mitigate trade tensions, even amidst institutional challenges such as the Appellate Body impasse, and illustrates how different groups of Members participate in these bodies. This phenomenon underscores the Goods Council's strategic position within the WTO structure, above the technical bodies and below its most political body, which has enabled it to become a useful barometer for the shifting dynamics of global trade frictions.
Staff Working Paper: Research ERSD-2024-04
Authors: Roy Santana and Adeet Dobhal
Manuscript date: 8 May 2024
Key Words:
Economic cooperation, Goods Council, trade concerns, specific trade concerns (STCs), trade disputes, trade frictions, transparency, development, trade diplomacy, WTO governance
JEL classification numbers:
F02, F13, F53, F55, K33
back to topDisclaimer
This is a working paper, and hence it represents research in progress. The opinions expressed in this paper are those of the authors. They do not represent the positions or opinions of the WTO or its Members and are without prejudice to Members' rights and obligations under the WTO. Any errors are attributable to the authors.
Download paper in pdf format (34 pages opens in a new window)