Structured discussions
Trade and environmental sustainability *
Fifty WTO members launched in November 2020 structured discussions to intensify work on trade and environmental sustainability. The Trade and Environmental Sustainability Structured Discussions (TESSD) are intended to complement the work of the Committee on Trade and Environment and other relevant WTO bodies and to support the objectives of the Marrakesh Agreement Establishing the WTO, which envisages a global trading system that protects and preserves the environment in accordance with sustainable development. Over 70 WTO members are currently cosponsoring the discussions, which are open to all members.
A Ministerial Statement adopted in December 2021 sets out future work for the initiative in areas such as trade and climate change, trade in environmental goods and services, circular economy, and sustainable supply chains.
On this page:
See also
TESSD at MC13
TESSD package for MC13
- Statement by TESSD Co-convenors - WT/MIN(24)/11
- Update of the TESSD Work Plan - WT/MIN(24)/11/Add.1
Outcome documents of Informal Working Groups
- Member Practices in the development of trade-related climate measures (TrCMs) - WT/MIN(24)/11/Add.2
- Analytical Summary on environmental goods and services and renewable energy - WT/MIN(24)/11/Add.3
- Mapping of trade aspects of circular economy along the product lifecycle - WT/MIN(24)/11/Add.4
- Compilation of experiences and considerations regarding subsidy design - WT/MIN(24)/11/Add.5
News
Participation
There are currently WTO members participating in the Trade and Environmental Sustainability Structured Discussions, including members from all regions and at all levels of development: least developed countries (LDCs), developing countries and developed countries. Ambassador Nadia Theodore (Canada) and Ambassador Ronald Saborío Soto (Costa Rica) jointly coordinate this initiative, which is open to all WTO members.
Meetings
15-16 April – TESSD Informal Working Group meetings
Working Group on Environmental Goods and Services
- Presentation by New Zealand on its experience with geothermal energy projects, including projects undertaken with development partners
- Presentation by Ocean Energy Europe (OEE): Ocean Energy: The next big thing in energy
Working Group on Subsidies
- Presentation by the International Air Transport Association (IATA) on Sustainable Aviation Fuels (SAFs)
- Presentation by the United Kingdom: Incentivising Sustainable Aviation Fuels: UK Policy Approaches. (04_Subsidies-United Kingdom)
- Presentation by the European Union on the ReFuelEU Aviation initiative for scaling up Sustainable Aviation Fuels (SAF)
Working Group on Circular Economy – Circularity
- Presentation by the International Resource Panel Secretariat on policy-relevant findings for resources, trade and circular economy transitions
- Presentation by the International Organization for Standardization (ISO) on standards and circular economy
- Presentation by Chatham House on trade and the circular economy
- Pre‑recorded video presentation by Chatham House on trade and the circular economy
Working Group on Trade-related Climate Measures
- Presentation by the WTO Secretariat based on the publication "Trade Policy Tools for Climate Action
- Presentation by UNCTAD based on the technical note "Mapping Trade-related Measures in the Nationally Determined Contributions"
25 January – TESSD Plenary meeting
- Convening notice (INF/TE/SSD/CN/12)
- Summary report 2023 (INF/TE/SSD/R/21)
Tentative meeting dates for 2023
20-21 November – TESSD Informal Working Groups meetings
Working Group on Trade-related Climate Measures
- Presentation by ITC on "Trade-related climate measures - the challenges and opportunities facing MSMEs in developing countries
- Presentation by IRENA on the role of green hydrogen in the energy transition and prospects for trade
- Presentation by WTO Secretariat on trade and trade policies along the hydrogen value chain
Working Group on Environmental Goods and Services
- Presentation by United Kingdom on hydrogen energy and trade
- Technical non-paper by the United Kingdom on Hydrogen Energy and Trade (INF/TE/SSD/W/30)
- Presentation by Uruguay on its Green Hydrogen Roadmap
- Presentation by Brazil on its Experience on using Biofuels to Decarbonize the Transport Sector
Working Group on Circular Economy – Circularity
- Presentation by UNEP: "Sustainability and Circularity in the Textile Value Chain"
- Presentation by UNECE: "Enabling circular trade in textile value chains: the role of traceability"
- Presentation by TESS on Approaches and good practices for the design of trade-related circular economy policies
Working Group on Subsidies
- Presentation by Switzerland: "Energy Strategy 2050: Promotion of Energy Efficiency and Renewable energy"
- Presentation by Australia: "Australia’s Clean Hydrogen Initiatives"
- Presentation by United States: "Fueling the future: Overview of the US Clean Hydrogen Landscape"
19-20 September – TESSD Informal Working Groups meetings
Working Group on Subsidies
- Presentation by WTO Secretariat on agri-environmental support notified to CoA
- Presentation by OECD on the environmental effects of agricultural subsidies
- Presentation by CBD on subsidies and incentives under the Kunming-Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework
- Presentation by Japan on its approach to incentivize sustainable agriculture
- Presentation by Uruguay on economic incentives in the agricultural sector with environmental objectives
Working Group on Circular Economy – Circularity
- Presentation by WCO on report, "Transition to a circular economy and implications for Customs administrations"
- Presentation by BRS Conventions on developments regarding the PIC procedure and e-waste
- Presentation by ASEAN on the ASEAN Framework for Circular Economy and implementation plan
- Presentation by Circular Innovation Lab on EPR and developing country challenges with used and end-of-life electronics
Working Group on Environmental Goods and Services
- Presentation by Australia on its experience in how to promote and facilitate trade in goods and services for environmental purposes –
- Presentation by UNCTAD on World Investment Report 2023 – Investing in Sustainable Energy for All
- Presentation by EDF Kenya on challenges and opportunities with renewable energy projects
- Presentation by WIPO on WIPO GREEN: The marketplace of Sustainable Technology
- Presentation by INPI on WIPO Green acceleration projects in Brazil
Working Group on Trade-related Climate Measures
- Presentation by IAI on carbon measurement standards and decarbonisation trajectories in the aluminium industry
- Presentation by EGA on its decarbonization plans and experience with carbon measurement standards
- Presentation by TESS on principles relevant for TrCMs
- Presentation by IISD on key design elements of border carbon adjustment (BCA) and priorities for international cooperation
11 July – TESSD Plenary meeting
- Convening notice (INF/TE/SSD/CN/11)
10-11 May – TESSD Informal Working Groups meetings
Working Group on Environmental Goods and Services
- Presentation by Ernst & Young on services inputs to the wind power value chain
- Presentation by UNCTAD on developing country opportunities in renewable energy technologies
- Technical paper by the United Kingdom on Offshore Wind Energy (INF/TE/SSD/W/26 and INF/TE/SSD/W/26/Add.1)
Working Group on Subsidies
- Presentation by IISD on tracking public financial flows from fossil fuels to clean energy
- Presentation by China on its green subsidy policy
- Presentation by the EU on policy support for transition to a low-carbon economy
- Presentation by Canada on its Federal Budget 2023: Affordable energy, green jobs and growing clean economy
Working Group on Trade-related Climate Measures
- Presentation by International Fertilizer Association (IFA) on decarbonization of the fertilizer industry
- Presentation by WTO Secretariat on trade in fertilizers
- Presentation by OECD on carbon footprints for food systems
- TESS update on work related to TrCMs
Working Group on Circular Economy – Circularity
- Presentation by Smart Prosperity Institute (SPI) on trade-related circular economy aspects of wind and solar energy
- Presentation by International Renewable Energy Agency (IRENA) on end-of-life management of solar PV
- Presentation by Ørsted on circularity in the renewables industry
- Presentation by WTO Secretariat on mapping of measures related to the circular economy in WTO
- TESS briefing on circular economy in clothing and textiles sector
16-17 March – TESSD Informal Working Groups meetings
- Informal summary by the Coordinators (INF/TE/SSD/R/16)
Working Group on Trade-related Climate Measures
Working Group on Subsidies
- Presentation by FAO on environmental effects of agricultural subsidies
- Presentation by Paraguay on good agricultural practices and environmental programmes
- Presentation by Brazil on subsidies and environmental sustainability of agriculture in Brazil
- Presentation by the EU on environmental sustainability in the EU's CAP
Working Group on Environmental Goods and Services
- Presentation by Secretariat on renewable energy services
- Technical paper by the United Kingdom “Building our Evidence Base around Environmental Goods” (INF/TE/SSD/W/23)
- Presentation by the UK on building an evidence base on EGS using value chain analysis (see also INF/TE/SSD/RD/12)
- Presentation by LONGi on trade-related challenges and opportunities in the solar energy sector
- Presentation by ISA on solar energy technology in developing countries
Working Group on Circular Economy – Circularity
- Presentation by the OECD on the study "Trade policies to promote the circular economy:…Lithium-ion batteries"
- Presentation by the National Board of Trade Sweden – Kommerskollegium on the study "Trade Rules for a circular economy: … Lithium-ion batteries".
- Presentation by the Secretariat on mapping of circular economy measures
- Presentation by Glencore on circularity of batteries and trade-related challenges and opportunities
- Presentation by CATL on circularity of batteries and trade-related challenges and opportunities
- Presentation by Closing the Loop on trade-related challenges in developing countries regarding battery recycling
2 December - TESSD High-Level Stocktaking Event
11 November
- Convening notice INF/TE/SSD/CN/10
- Aide-mémoire INF/TE/SSD/R/13
4-5 October – TESSD Informal Working Groups meetings
Working Group on Environmental Goods and Services
- Presentation by Secretariat on non-tariff measures (NTMs) related to climate change and relevant work in the WTO
- Presentation by Secretariat on trade in environmental services in the Special Session of the Council for Trade in Services (CTS-SS)
- Presentation by APEC on promoting trade in environmental services in the APEC region
Working Group on Trade-related Climate Measures
- Presentation by ISO on international carbon accounting standards
- Presentation by Secretariat on trade-related implications of different carbon-pricing approaches
- Presentation by IMF on possible design and implications of international carbon price floors
- Presentation by OECD on its recent and ongoing work on carbon pricing
Working Group on Circular Economy – Circularity
- Presentation by WCO on challenges in distinguishing used goods and recyclable materials from waste in customs procedures
- Presentation by BRS Secretariat on identification of used goods, PIC procedures and updates regarding e-waste
- Presentation by OECD on cross-border reverse supply chains
- Presentation by Secretariat on trade-related policy issues and elements that may serve as a basis for a mapping exercise
Working Group on Subsidies
- Presentation by Secretariat on environment-related subsidies included in the WTO Environmental Database (EDB)
- Presentation by OECD on environmental impacts of industrial subsidies
- Presentation by IISD on evidence for evaluating environmental effects of fisheries subsidies
19-20 July - TESSD Plenary meeting
- Convening notice INF/TE/SSD/CN/9/Rev.1
- Informal summary by the Coordinators INF/TE/SSD/R/12)
- Presentation by the United Kingdom on how technical barriers to trade impact trade in environmental goods
Regional Experiences
Asia-Pacific
- Presentation by Ambassador Falemaka, Permanent Delegation of the Pacific Islands Forum (PIF)
- Presentation by Carlos Kuriyama, APEC Secretariat
- Presentation by Nguyễn Thị Minh Thuý, VIETRADE
Africa
- Presentation by Davinah Milenge Uwella, African Development Bank
- Presentation by Marie Veyrier, Global Shea Alliance
- Presentation by Yai-Fatou Gaye, Earth Builder Association
- Video by Earth Builder Association
South and Central America and the Caribbean
- Presentation by Hugo Alexander Chavarría Miranda, Inter-American Institute for Cooperation on Agriculture (IICA)
- Presentation by David Vivas Eugui, UNCTAD and Rachel Gaughan, CITES
- Video on Blue BioTrade in the Eastern Caribbean
- Presentation by Santiago Peralta and Carla Borbotó, PACARI
17-18 May - TESSD Informal Working Groups meetings
- Convening notice INF/TE/SSD/CN/8
Working Group on Environmental Goods and Services
- Summary report INF/TE/SSD/R/8
- Presentation by IRENA on Renewable Energy
- Summary of Discussions of Stakeholder Workshop hosted by the United Kingdom
Working Group on Trade-related Climate Measures
- Summary report INF/TE/SSD/R/9
- Presentation by World Bank on measuring carbon pricing and carbon content of production and transport
- Presentation by UNIDO on Climate-focused Priorities in Developing Countries
- Discussion Paper by the United States on Circular Economy and Climate Change
Working Group on Circular Economy – Circularity
- Summary report INF/TE/SSD/R/10
- Presentation by IKEA on A Circular IKEA
- Presentation by RAGN-SELLS on Circular Solutions against a Global Food Crisis
- Presentation by WEF on Circular Trade
Working Group on Subsidies
- Summary report INF/TE/SSD/R/11
- Presentation by OECD on OECD Inventory of Support Measures for Fossil Fuels
- Presentation by UNEP on joint UNEP-FAO-UNDB report on agricultural support measures
31 March and 11 April - TESSD Plenary meeting
- Convening notice INF/TE/SSD/CN/7/Rev.1
- Note by the Secretariat INF/TE/SSD/W/18
- Informal summary by the Coordinators INF/TE/SSD/R/7)
Presentations
- Secretariat presentation on EDB and TRCMs
- Secretariat presentation on Climate Change Modelling Workshop
- ODI-EIF presentation
- Secretariat presentation on experiences with EGS promotion
- IISD presentation on Fossil Fuel Subsidies
7 February
- Convening notice INF/TE/SSD/CN/6/Rev.1
- 2022 Work Plan INF/TE/SSD/W/17/Rev.1
- Informal summary by the Coordinators INF/TE/SSD/R/6
4 November
- Convening Notice INF/TE/SSD/CN/5
- Informal summary by the Coordinators INF/TE/SSD/R/5
16-17 September
- Convening Notice INF/TE/SSD/CN/4/Add.1
- Informal summary by the Coordinators INF/TE/SSD/R/4
19 July
- Convening notice INF/TE/SSD/CN/3/Rev. 1
- Informal summary by the Coordinators INF/TE/SSD/R/3
26-28 May
- Informal summary by the Coordinators INF/TE/SSD/R/2
5 March
- Informal summary by the Coordinators INF/TE/SSD/R/1
Documents submitted by WTO Members *
Date |
Submitted by |
Document number |
---|---|---|
23 May 2023 |
United Kingdom |
INF/TE/SSD/W/26 INF/TE/SSD/W/26/Add.1 |
23 March 2023 |
United Kingdom |
INF/TE/SSD/W/23 |
4 May 2022 |
United States |
INF/TE/SSD/W/19 |
16 July 2021 |
Australia |
INF/TE/SSD/W/16 |
14 July 2021 |
United Kingdom |
INF/TE/SSD/W/15 |
26 May 2021 |
Japan |
INF/TE/SSD/W/13 |
26 May 2021 |
Brazil, Ecuador, El Salvador and Paraguay |
INF/TE/SSD/W/12 |
6 May 2021 |
TESSD Coordinators |
INF/TE/SSD/W/11 |
22 March 2021 |
Japan |
INF/TE/SSD/W/10 |
3 March 2021 |
Australia; Korea, Republic of; Singapore |
INF/TE/SSD/W/9 |
5 February 2021 |
Korea, Republic of |
INF/TE/SSD/W/8 |
8 February 2021 |
European Union |
INF/TE/SSD/W/7 |
5 February 2021 |
United Kingdom |
INF/TE/SSD/W/6 |
12 February 2021 |
Iceland |
INF/TE/SSD/W/5 |
8 February 2021 |
Switzerland |
INF/TE/SSD/W/4 |
8 February 2021 |
Canada |
INF/TE/SSD/W/3 |
5 February 2021 |
Japan |
INF/TE/SSD/W/2 |
5 February 2021 |
New Zealand |
INF/TE/SSD/W/1 |
Scope of the discussions
In a joint communication issued in November 2020 during WTO Trade and Environment Week 2020, the 50 co-sponsors said they would collaborate to identify areas for future work to help the WTO address sustainable development challenges more effectively and would work on possible environmental sustainability “actions and deliverables”.
In addition, the co-sponsors noted their willingness to work alongside relevant international organizations and other actors to support the technical assistance and capacity-building needs on trade and environmental sustainability of least-developed countries (LDCs) and other WTO members. The joint communication also highlights the intention to promote transparency through intensified dialogue and information sharing.
State of play
To organize their work, the participants have launched "structured discussions" for interested WTO members. These discussions include a dialogue with the business community, civil society, international organizations and academic institutions. These efforts seek to complement and support the work of other WTO committees and bodies, including the Committee on Trade and Environment.
During the TESSD meetings held so far, participants have discussed topics such as trade-related climate measures, sustainable supply chains, environmental goods and services, circular economy, green aid for trade, fossil fuel subsidy reform, and sustainable food and agriculture. Opportunities and challenges for sustainable trade for developing countries and LDCs have been given consideration across these topics.
At a joint event on 15 December 2021, co-sponsors of three environmental initiatives - TESSD, the Informal Dialogue on Plastics Pollution and Sustainable Plastics Trade (IDP), and Fossil Fuel Subsidy Reform (FFSR) - launched their respective Ministerial Statements. WTO Director-General Ngozi Okonjo-Iweala joined ministers from the initiative co-coordinators, heads of international organizations and representatives from business and civil society groups in welcoming the initiatives and highlighting that trade, and the WTO, are part of the solution to climate change and environmental degradation.
The TESSD Ministerial Statement (WT/MIN(21)/6/Rev.2) of the Trade and Environmental Sustainability Structured Discussions (TESSD) has 71 co-sponsors, which account for around 84% of global trade. The Statement sets out future work for the initiative in areas such as trade and climate change, trade in environmental goods and services, circular economy, sustainable supply chains, capacity building and technical assistance for sustainable trade, and subsidies. It also foresees a high-level stocktaking event towards the end of 2022.
The TESSD Work Plan 2022 (INF/TE/SSD/W/17/Rev.1) provides for the creation of Informal Working Groups on (i) trade-related climate measures; (ii) environmental goods and services; (iii) circular economy - circularity; and (iv) subsidies, to allow for more in-depth discussions and make progress towards tangible outcomes. Working Groups will be led by facilitators, who will report back to formal TESSD meetings.
In December 2022, a high-level event took place to take stock of the progress made by the discussions so far and to highlight priorities for further work ahead of MC13 scheduled to take place at end-February 2024. Opening the event, Director-General Ngozi Okonjo-Iweala called the structured discussions a “trailblazer at the WTO” and praised members for exploring new trade solutions to environmental issues.
In preparation for the event, a summary report capturing the range of TESSD work in 2022 was issued. In addition, the TESSD co-convenors (Canada and Costa Rica) circulated a statement recognizing the progress made in 2022 and indicating how participating members would focus their work in 2023.
* The documents on this page relate to an initiative among a group of WTO members and are not part of a multilaterally agreed WTO process. Back to text
Share
Key TESSD documents
Problems viewing this page? If so, please contact [email protected] giving details of the operating system and web browser you are using.